The solution to GotW #4 is now available:

GotW #4 Solution: Class Mechanics (updated for C++11/14)

by Herb Sutter

From the article:

... To see why, consider the following canonical forms for how operator+= and operator+ should normally be implemented for some type T.

T& T::operator+=( const T& other ) {
    //...
    return *this;
}

 

T operator+( T a, const T& b ) {
    a += b;
    return a;
}

Did you notice that one parameter is passed by value, and one by reference? That’s because if you’re going to copy from a parameter anyway, it’s often better to pass it by value, which will naturally enable a move operation if the caller passes a temporary object such as in expressions like (val1 * val2) + val3. We’ll see more on parameter passing in a future GotW. ...

.